Thursday, January 7, 2010

Sherlock Holmes Movie Review


Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s evergreen creation, the sleuth Sherlock Holmes whose intellectual capabilities have always left readers spellbound, has been brought to the screen before. Now Guy Ritchie tries his hand at it, and how! The movie explores characteristics of Sherlock that have been mentioned in the book, but seldom made their way into the television adaptations. A lot of effort has gone into defining the nuances of the character; notably the eccentric nature, the adeptness in martial arts and his relationship with Watson. The movie also takes some distinct turns away from the book – the witty exchanges, Holmes’ disregard for personal hygiene, the fast pace and the importance to action. The end result is a facelift for Sherlock Holmes from the stuffy, tight upper lipped intellectual to a modern, eccentric genius, more suited to today’s audiences.

The movie starts with Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson capturing Lord Blackwood, who has murdered five women in his practice of black magic. Lord Blackwood is sentenced to death by hanging, though he warns Holmes that this was only the beginning and that he would rise from the dead. And true to his word, he does. It is now up to Sherlock and Watson to stop him before he succeeds in his plan of ruling England, and then the world. And, to make matters worse, Holmes has to deal with Watson’s relationship with Mary Morstan and the fact that Watson will no longer be his partner. What follows is a whirlwind ride with twists and turns, the beautiful but deceptive Irene Adler, a secret society, a huge French speaking adversary, and innumerable perilous sequences, all leading to a conclusion that is pure Sherlock in its logic and completeness. To give out any more of the plot would be sacrilege, which I do not intend.

The movie is different from other Guy Ritchie movies (thankfully showcasing that he can be versatile), though many of his creative styles and trademarks are evident. He skilfully handles the job of reinventing Holmes while maintaining the essence of the novels. I can’t say this is his best movie, but it is definitely not short on style or substance – thanks to a good screenplay (though over the top at times), great camerawork and smart editing. The scenes where Holmes anticipates incidents in his mind are noteworthy. And let’s not forget the art direction, which brings the late 19th century England to life. The feel is further accentuated by Hans Zimmer's unique score.

As for performances, Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law are perfectly cast as the lead pair. The chemistry they share as the squabbling duo is one of the highlights of the movie. Mark Strong gives a chilling performance as Lord Blackwood. Rachel McAdams is efficient as Irene Adler, though she may not have been able to hold her own among the other performances. The rest of the cast provide able support.

So, what’s the final verdict, you ask? Elementary, my dear Watson. The movie is fast paced, action packed, and also exercises your grey cells; in short - a winner. Some may argue that the movie could have been better, but no one can dispute that it is a fun filled ride.

For my astronomically inclined readers who suggested that I introduce the star rating system for my reviews, ****.

2 comments:

Unknown said...

I get to write the first comment... And it is fair all the same since i accompanied him to the movie... Unlike him, I have read a few Sherlock Holmes stories and though the characteristic nuances are followed to the letter, the movie and the story-telling is unlike Arthur Conan Doyle. It explores on new aspects of Holmes' personality namely, a show of his martial arts expertise and a sharp sense of intelligent humor.

Even though the story handling is different yet it never lacks on the thrill, suspense and a roller-coaster ride characteristic of Holmes and Watson's investigations.

All in all, it's a movie worth watching even if you have to forego the joy of watching it in your favorite theatre (Fame Shankarnag) and settle for a distant one and rather uncomfortable seats (Fame Lido). But the movie is so engrossing that you forget all these minor problems.

Sujith said...

Bang on the target... Actually I read your review first and then saw the movie, Frankly I was not even aware of the movie before you mentioned it...

the movie not only does make you sit at the edge of your seat, but also make you fall off it, during some really funny moments..... especially, the scene where holmes tries his drugs on watson's dog(or was it their's) Downey's, for sure, grabbing a nominee during this time's academies...

Great review, seriously, write a mail to rajiv masand and ask for his suggestion as to how to hone and commercialize your talent in movie reviewing.